Which is better: Metal or shingle roof? Many customers considering a replacement or upgraded roof are wanting to know what options are best. Never fret, we’ve got you covered. In this article, we will look at two of the most popular types of roofing materials and compare each type of roof in detail, so that you can make an informed decision. We also highlight some of the key factors to consider when making your decision, so that you can get the best possible outcome from your new roofing project. We will cover a few of the key points for debate, such as:
  • Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?
  • Are metal roofs better than shingles?
  • Is it true that you can actually get a metal roof that looks like shingles!?

The Pros and Cons of Metal & Shingle Roofs

New shingle roof

Shingled Roof Disadvantages

One of the biggest disadvantages of a shingle roof is that they tend to be less durable than other types of roofs. This means that they may need to be replaced more often, which can be a costly expense. In addition, shingle roofs are also more susceptible to leaks and damage from high winds and hail.

Shingled Roof Advantages

A shingle roof is a type of roofing made that is made up of overlapping tiles or shingles. Each tile or shingle has an adhesive back and can be secured to the roof with nails. Because shingle roofs are relatively easy to install, they’re very popular among homeowners and businesses who want an inexpensive roofing option that still offers good protection against weather damage. The biggest advantage to the shingled roof is that it can be made maintained relatively easy and it’s the best value for the investment when it comes to roofing. Here’s the rundown: Asphalt Shingles: Most known as laminated or dimensional shingles, architectural roofing shingles are among the highest quality roofing products made. Usually, they are baked in a heavy fiberglass mat base and ceramic-coated granules that are tightly embedded in carefully refined, water-resistant asphalt. Copper particles are one of the most expensive components when it comes to shingles manufacturing. Metal Roof Shingles: Yes, you can get a metal roof that looks like shingles! They are the most durable of all roofing options. They can last up to 40 years or longer and have a more traditional look and are less expensive to install than other types of roofs. Wood Shingle: One of the oldest types of roofing material used. They were developed in England in the late 1600s and were used for hundreds of years until they were replaced by metal and other more modern options. Wood shingles are still used today but are typically only on older homes or those that have been converted to historic preservation. They can be found in a variety of colors, designs, and styles. Plastic Roof Shingles: A great alternative to traditional asphalt or wood shingles. They are made from a durable, weather-resistant plastic material that looks and feels like metal. Plastic roof shingles have some of the same benefits as metal roof shingles, including durability and resistance to water damage, but they also come in a variety of colors and designs that can complement your home’s architectural features.

Metal Roof Disadvantages

One of the biggest disadvantages to the metal roof is the cost. Metal roofs can be two to three times the cost of a traditional shingle roof. Another disadvantage is the noise. A metal roof can be quite noisy during a rainstorm or when hail hits. And finally, metal roofs are not as easy to repair as a traditional shingle roof.

Metal Roof Advantages

A metal roof is a roofing system made from metal pieces or tiles. It is a popular choice for both commercial and residential buildings because of its durability and long lifespan. In fact, Metal roofs can last for decades, and they are recyclable, making them a sustainable choice for your home or business. Metal roofs are also fire-resistant and energy-efficient, making them a great choice for any climate. The biggest advantage to metal roofing is that it’s the most durable in comparison to any shingled roof option, not to mention that it can add around 10-15% more value than traditional shingles can. Additionally, a well-installed metal roof can last 50 years or longer and is highly resistant to weather damage. Metal roofing can also be customized with a variety of colors and patterns which can be a great way to give your home a touch of personality.

Metal Roof vs Shingles Price

Shingle roof
So, which is cheaper metal or shingle roof? This will depend on a number of factors, including the type of metal or shingle roof that you choose. It’s fair to say that while a metal roof will likely be more expensive to install, it will probably last longer and require fewer repairs than a shingle roof. However, if you decide to go with a shingle roof, make sure that the manufacturer’s warranty is included in your purchase price. If not, then it might be worth investing in one to avoid future repair costs.

Metal Roof Cost

The cost of installing metal roofing can be anything from $600-$1200 (per 100 sq. ft.) as a rough guide, although the exact figure will be different for every homeowner.

Shingle Roof Cost

A shingle roof is likely to cost somewhere between $450-$700, depending on the exact material you choose and the size of your property. Disclaimer: Prices for roofing systems are always subject to change. So, remember to speak with an experienced professional to help you determine the cost for your own needs.

Which is Better – Metal or Shingle Roof?

Roofing contractor in Pittsburgh
When it comes to your home’s roof, metal should definitely be an option that you consider alongside traditional materials like shingles or tiles. Metal roofs are more durable and last longer, making them a cost-effective choice in the long run, although the up-front costs can be higher. They also provide superior insulation properties as compared to other types of roofs. In addition to these benefits, metal roofs are often considered environmentally friendly due to their low emissions profile. They can also be designed to look sleek and modern, unlike some conventional roofing materials that tend to date quickly. On the other hand, you’ve learned that shingles are an affordable option and can even come made out of metal, wood, and plastic. If you’re looking for an upgrade on your home’s existing roof system, then metal may be the perfect choice for you! Roofing shouldn’t just come down to the question of are metal roofs cheaper than shingles. At the end of the day, the choice between a metal or shingle roof is ultimately a personal decision. Both types of roofs have their own benefits and drawbacks, so it’s important to research each option carefully. If you decide to go with a metal roof, be sure to take into account the weather conditions in your area. If you choose a shingle roof, make sure the materials are compatible with your climate and home. Ultimately, the most important thing is to get a roof that will protect your home from the elements and keep you and your family safe. In the meantime, read more about how to choose a roofing contractor for roof repair or replacement.
Author: Gino Slipko, Lisa Dunn